Book review: The Good Doctor by Damon Galgut

the good doctor damon galgutFrank Eloff is a world-weary doctor in a remote South African hospital. His world is upturned when an idealistic young Laurence Waters is posted to work with him. The hospital was opened under apartheid, in what was deemed a homeland (impoverished parts of the country that were set aside by the regime for illusory ‘self-determination’).

Apartheid has gone, but their hospital somehow remains, poorly resourced, its staff all waiting for something to happen, the few serious cases they encounter transferred out. Some staff see salvation in moving on, others wallow in resignation. Laurence is young, idealistic, determined to shake things up. But there are complex social and political forces in play, and his actions have terrible consequences.

The Good Doctor is the perfect short novel. Frank’s voice is so intense that any more would be too much. It takes you into a world that is uniquely its own, a dark, claustrophobic place where nothing is certain or familiar, where you are constantly stumbling for sense, where the emotions are vivid but the facts are contingent.

Galgut’s writing is brilliant: terse, fierce, like being jabbed in the chest relentlessly. It is astonishing but you don’t quite know how it’s done. Like the greatest prose, the magic somehow rests in the space between the words.

The Good Doctor doesn’t preach or explain. While it dissects the cruel absurdities of oppression and corruption, the word apartheid doesn’t appear once. You experience the world anew, without assumptions, preconceptions or easy explanations. You must decipher images, snatches of dialogue, gestures, the arrangement of a room.

This novel has my favourite kind of ending, neither too tightly tied up, nor hanging unresolved. The world at the end has irrevocably changed, but it is for the reader to decide how.

View The Good Doctor on Goodreads

For another short, intense literary novel, take a look at my review of Hot Milk by Deborah Levy.


  1. Short and intense novels–what a great reading project! I’ve not read this one of his, but I just read Arctic Summer last year and was really impressed. Did you enjoy this one enough to read more of his writing as well?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Totally agree! Love this writer’s work. Sometimes hard for those of us who are not from that country and don’t know the history to understand the complexities and nuances. But the writing is compelling and we are drawn in despite our lack of knowledge.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.